Each year, St. Ambrose Episcopal Church in Raleigh celebrates Men’s Day, a special Sunday that’s dedicated to fellowship, spiritual reflection, and honoring the contributions of men in our church and broader community. This year, we were honored to welcome Superior Court Judge Keith O. Gregory as our guest speaker. Though introduced through his distinguished legal career, Judge Gregory set aside the formality of his title to speak simply as Keith, sharing a candid and deeply personal testimony of faith, accountability, and the transforming power of God’s grace.
What followed was a remarkable journey through professional triumphs, personal struggles, painful lessons, and life-changing encounters with God, all centered on a simple declaration:
“I’m a flawed man, but God still loves me.”
When God Calls, Show Up
Judge Gregory opened with humor, acknowledging that he had originally been invited to speak at St. Ambrose the previous year but was forced to cancel after contracting COVID-19. When Anthony Flanigan invited him again, he confessed to feeling a moment of panic. After all, St. Ambrose had been waiting an entire year. Surely, he joked, they might expect an extraordinary message.
Behind the humor, however, was a conviction that would frame everything he shared. Twenty-one years earlier, Judge Gregory had made a promise to himself and, more importantly, to God: when called to do something, even when reluctant, he would show up and ask God to show out. And so, standing before St. Ambrose, he offered a simple prayer:
“I’m here, God, and I’m asking you to show out.”
He then turned to a more personal reflection. Following a nationally publicized trial, Judge Gregory had received considerable praise for his courtroom demeanor and professionalism. Compliments arrived from across the country and even overseas, and he admitted that reading the glowing commentary was intoxicating.
Amid that praise, though, he felt a familiar tap on his shoulder: a reminder from God that his work was not for his own glory. Before taking the bench each morning, he explained, he kneels to pray the Lord’s Prayer, asking God to guide his decisions and help him do what is right. The praise of others, while gratifying, could never replace that responsibility. People might celebrate us one day and criticize us the next, while God’s presence is constant.
That realization led him to a question that would become the heart of his message: In whose eyes do we seek to be perfect: humanity’s or God’s?
A Flawed Man, Loved by God
Judge Gregory reminded St. Ambrose that Scripture is filled with imperfect people whom God nevertheless called to extraordinary purposes. Abraham acted out of fear. Moses struggled with his own limitations. David committed grievous wrongs. Peter denied knowing Jesus. Yet God continued to work through their lives, offering a powerful reminder that God’s purposes have never depended upon human perfection.
Judge Gregory was careful not to compare his accomplishments to those biblical figures. Instead, he identified with their humanity: their mistakes, weaknesses, and need for grace. He then invited St. Ambrose to look beyond his judicial title. For the remainder of his message, he wanted them to hear from Keith Gregory, the man.
And Keith had a story to tell.
The Cost of Free Will
Raised in a churchgoing family, Judge Gregory recalled singing in the children’s choir and participating in church programs. His mother, a schoolteacher, had ensured that faith was part of his upbringing.
When he arrived at college, however, he discovered two newfound freedoms. First, he no longer had to eat the red beets his mother insisted he eat on Sundays. Second, he no longer had to attend church. St. Ambrose laughed as he acknowledged that, years later, he discovered both beets and church were actually good for him.
The humor opened the door to a much more serious reflection. God gives us free will, Judge Gregory explained, but our choices carry consequences. Choosing faith requires surrender, discipline, and trust, while choosing to turn away carries a cost as well.
As he progressed through college, law school, marriage, fatherhood, and the beginnings of a successful legal career, he also developed an increasingly destructive relationship with alcohol. He described a painful encounter in 1996, when another attorney directed a racial slur toward him in the courthouse. Angry and humiliated, he confronted the man but felt God directing him away from a confrontation that could jeopardize his career. He listened, yet afterward, instead of turning to God with his pain, he turned to alcohol. In one of the sermon’s most striking expressions, he described how he began repeatedly falling into a bottle instead of the Bible.
The pattern continued. In 1999, he was handed divorce papers at the courthouse, and again, he sought refuge in alcohol. He offered a sobering observation about that choice: when we take our problems into a bar, they do not disappear. They remain outside, waiting for us when we leave.
Even as his professional life flourished, his personal life was unraveling. He opened his own law firm in 2000 and enjoyed considerable financial success, but the freedom of being his own boss also allowed him to drink without the accountability of an employer. The money accumulated, yet his physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual health were slipping away. Success, he had discovered, was not the same as peace.
From Insurrection to Resurrection
Then came January 5, 2005. Judge Gregory described being home one evening, overwhelmed by physical distress and fear, while his young son slept upstairs. Suddenly, he confronted a terrifying possibility: What if his son came downstairs the next morning and found his father dead?
The thought shook him. He called his son’s mother, Tammy, who helped him through the immediate crisis. Then, alone in his home, he fell to his knees and cried out to God, admitting that he could no longer continue living as he had been. In that moment, he recalled hearing a simple instruction:
“Take one step forward.”
He did. And, as he told St. Ambrose, January 5, 2005 was the last day alcohol touched his lips. The insurrection alcohol had on his life ended. He moved toward resurrection.
The testimony drew applause, but Judge Gregory was clear that he had not shared it to seek recognition. He wanted St. Ambrose to understand what happened next. The following day, January 6, became a personal anniversary of rebirth. He described God bringing about a revolution within his heart, turning him away from the life he had known and restoring what addiction had gradually taken from him.
Still, the transformation did not mean the work was finished. He attended Alcoholics Anonymous, found a sponsor, embraced the discipline of recovery, and acknowledged his responsibility for the choices ahead. He understood that he could not undertake that work simply for his son, his mother, or anyone else; he had to make the decision for himself. Faith had asked him to take the first step, and recovery required him to keep walking.
His testimony brought new meaning to the truth he had shared earlier: free will comes at a cost, and while he had learned that lesson the hard way, he had also discovered that some costs are worth paying.
From Personal Redemption to Public Responsibility
Having shared the most vulnerable chapters of his life, Judge Gregory returned to the story of his legal career, now heard through an entirely different lens. In 2010, five years into his sobriety, he interviewed with Governor Beverly Perdue for an appointment to the district court bench. He recalled sitting in the interview, marveling at how far his life had come. Whatever the outcome, he had already experienced something far more important: a transformed life.
He received the appointment. On February 18, 2010, his first day as a district court judge, he began putting his convictions into practice. He encouraged young men appearing in his courtroom to present themselves with dignity, tuck in their shirts, and pull up their pants, not simply out of respect for him as a judge, but out of respect for the justice system and themselves. When some attorneys warned that his approach could cost him votes, his response reflected the priorities that now guided his life: losing an election was something he could accept; disregarding what he understood God calling him to do was not.
Then came an unexpected encounter. In 2011, the attorney who had directed a racial slur toward him fifteen years earlier appeared in his courtroom. This time, the man addressed him as “Your Honor” and complimented Judge Gregory on his work.
The moment could have become an opportunity for retaliation or triumph, and Judge Gregory admitted that he briefly considered reminding the attorney of their earlier encounter. Instead, he felt God directing him toward a different response. He simply said, “Thank you.”
For the young people listening, Judge Gregory emphasized the significance of that decision. How we respond when others demean or mistreat us can profoundly shape the course of our lives. His message was not that injustice should be ignored, but that anger need not determine our actions or our futures.
Trusting God Through Opposition
Judge Gregory went on to describe other moments when professional relationships were tested and his faith was called upon to guide his response. He recalled being threatened by a former supervisor and feeling fear give way to a profound sense of God’s presence, an experience that challenged him to examine where he placed his trust. He had once elevated influential people because they had supported his career, but he came to believe that no person, however powerful or helpful, should occupy the place in his life reserved for God.
That lesson remained with him in 2018, when he sought appointment to the superior court bench. A fellow judge, who had previously supported him, told him emphatically that he would not receive the appointment. Judge Gregory continued forward, doing the work before him and trusting God with what he could not control. Governor Roy Cooper ultimately appointed him to the position, and in an unexpected turn, the same judge who had opposed his appointment later offered support for his election campaign.
For Judge Gregory, these experiences illustrated a lesson he had learned repeatedly: other people do not have the final word over one’s purpose. Faith requires us to act with integrity, remain humble, and trust God beyond the limits of our own understanding.
Still Flawed. Still Loved.
As his message drew to a close, Judge Gregory returned to the public praise that had prompted his opening reflection. He had experienced professional success, public recognition, and extraordinary personal transformation, yet none of it had made him perfect. He was still the same flawed man who had struggled, stumbled, made mistakes, and needed God’s grace.
And that, he reminded St. Ambrose, was precisely the point. God’s love had not waited for him to become flawless. It had been present when he was lost, when he was struggling, when he reached for help, when he took his first step toward recovery, and through every imperfect day that followed.
His testimony invited all of us to examine our own lives, not through the narrow measure of worldly success or the approval of others, but through the possibilities of grace, humility, and faithful choices. For the men of St. Ambrose, and for everyone gathered, his words offered a powerful vision of strength: not the strength of appearing invulnerable, but the courage to acknowledge weakness, accept accountability, seek help, and allow God to work through us.
Judge Gregory concluded where he began: with an acknowledgment of his imperfections and gratitude for the God who continues to love him. His story leaves us with a simple but profound invitation. Whatever burdens we carry, whatever mistakes lie behind us, and however uncertain the road ahead may seem, we can choose to take one step forward and trust that God’s grace will meet us there.
We invite you to watch Judge Keith Gregory’s moving Men’s Day testimony, beginning at approximately 41:13 in the service recording.
Recent Comments